Food & Kitchen

Hard Water vs Soft Water: Health Effects, Eczema and Softened Water

Promising researchLast reviewed By the Longer Living Guide editorial team

How we grade ›Sources checked on Our independence ›

We may earn a commission if you buy through our links. How we choose ›

Quick answer

Hard water just contains more calcium and magnesium; it causes limescale, but the UK sets no health limit for hardness and observational studies even link it to slightly lower heart disease deaths. Softened water from a home softener has sodium added, so the Drinking Water Inspectorate advises keeping an unsoftened kitchen tap for drinking, and the NHS says never to use it for baby formula. A UK trial found water softeners did not improve existing childhood eczema.

Evidence grade: moderate. The practical advice on softened water (keep an unsoftened kitchen tap, never use it for baby feeds) comes straight from the Drinking Water Inspectorate and the NHS. The health links are weaker: the heart findings are observational, and a UK randomised trial found a water softener did not improve existing childhood eczema. Sources checked 17 November 2026.

Hard water vs soft water: the short answer

Hard water simply contains more dissolved calcium and magnesium, picked up as rain soaks through chalk and limestone. It causes limescale, but it is not a health problem: UK drinking water regulations set no standard for hardness, calcium or magnesium at all (DWI). Soft water is kinder to kettles, boilers and showers. The one thing to watch is artificially softened water from a home softener, which swaps calcium and magnesium for sodium.

How hard is your water?

The Drinking Water Inspectorate classifies hardness in milligrams per litre (mg/l) as calcium carbonate (DWI):

Hardness (mg/l as calcium carbonate)Classification
Up to 100Soft
100 to 150Slightly hard
150 to 200Moderately hard
200 to 300Hard
Over 300Very hard

Hardness depends on local geology, so it can change from one town to the next. The quickest way to find yours is to enter your postcode on your water company's website; for example, United Utilities offers a postcode checker and notes that no supply in the North West is artificially softened by the company (United Utilities).

Water above about 200 mg/l tends to leave scale in kettles and pipes, while water at 100 mg/l or less can be more corrosive to pipework (DWI).

Is hard water bad for your health?

No health-based guideline exists for hardness in the UK (DWI). Hard water supplies a little calcium and magnesium, but food is the main source of both.

Heart health. For decades, studies have noticed that people in hard-water areas tend to have slightly lower rates of death from heart and circulatory disease. A 2023 systematic review found 17 of 25 studies reported this protective link (Bykowska-Derda et al. 2023, Foods). But every study was observational, the pooled analysis used only three central European studies, and the results varied hugely between them, so the authors said more research is needed. The link is interesting, not proven. The DWI still advises water companies that artificially soften supplies to keep total hardness at 150 mg/l or more because of this early evidence (DWI).

Does hard water cause eczema?

This is the most common worry, and the evidence splits into two questions:

  • Treating existing eczema: no benefit found. The UK Softened Water Eczema Trial randomised 336 children aged six months to 16 years with moderate to severe eczema in hard-water areas. After 12 weeks, children in homes with an ion-exchange water softener did no better on objective eczema measures than those without one (University of Nottingham).
  • Preventing eczema in babies: an open question. A study of 1,303 three-month-old babies in England found that higher calcium carbonate in home water was linked to more visible eczema (adjusted odds ratio 1.87) (Perkin et al. 2016). That shows an association, not cause. A small pilot trial then installed softeners before birth for 78 families: 33% of babies in softened homes had visible eczema at six months versus 48% of controls, but the trial was too small to be conclusive (Jabbar-Lopez et al. 2021).

The NHS lists soap, detergents, pets, pollen, dust mites and some foods as common eczema triggers and advises washing with an emollient instead of soap (NHS). If you are thinking of a softener mainly for a child's eczema, speak to your GP first, as the trial evidence does not support it as a treatment.

Is softened water OK to drink?

Most home water softeners work by ion exchange, swapping calcium and magnesium for sodium. That changes the advice:

  • Keep an unsoftened kitchen tap for drinking and cooking. The DWI advises this, and notes some softeners can add enough sodium to risk breaching the drinking water standard (DWI).
  • Never use artificially softened water for baby formula. The NHS says to use freshly boiled tap water that has not been softened (NHS).
  • Take extra care on a low-sodium diet. The DWI flags people on low-sodium diets and premature babies, whose kidneys handle sodium less well (DWI). Ask your GP if you have been told to cut salt.
  • Watch older pipes. Artificially softened water can be aggressive to plumbing and may pick up copper and lead (DWI).

Naturally soft water from your supplier is different: it has not had sodium added, so this advice does not apply to it.

Hard vs soft water at home

Hard waterSoft water (natural)Artificially softened water
LimescaleYes, in kettles, showers and boilersLittle or noneLittle or none
Soap and shampooLathers lessLathers easilyLathers easily
DrinkingFine; no UK hardness limitFineKeep a separate unsoftened tap
Baby formulaUse freshly boiled tap waterUse freshly boiled tap waterDo not use
PipesScale build-upCan be more corrosiveCan be more corrosive

What can you do about hard water?

  • For taste and kettle scale: a filter jug with a limescale cartridge is the cheapest option. Our water filter jug guide covers hard-water cartridges from BRITA, Aqua Optima and Phox.
  • For drinking water quality as well: an under-sink filter with a limescale stage; see our under-sink water filter guide.
  • For the whole house: a salt-based softener, fitted by a qualified plumber with an unsoftened drinking tap kept in place. The DWI says any device must meet the Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999, and suggests checking with your water company first (DWI).
  • For limescale only: descaling kettles and showerheads with citric acid or vinegar is cheap and avoids harsher chemicals.

Bottom line

Hard water is a limescale nuisance, not a health risk, and some observational data even link it to better heart health. Softened water is pleasant for washing, but it is not the right water for drinking taps or baby feeds. Softeners have not been shown to treat eczema, and whether softening water around birth helps prevent it is still being tested. If you soften your water, keep one unsoftened tap in the kitchen.

Frequently asked questions

Is hard water bad for you?

+

No. The UK sets no health standard for water hardness, and hard water supplies a little calcium and magnesium. Its main downside is limescale.

Is it better to drink hard or soft water?

+

Both natural hard and soft water meet UK drinking standards. Some observational studies link hard water to lower heart disease deaths, but this is not proven. Artificially softened water is the one to avoid for drinking.

Can you drink softened water?

+

The DWI advises keeping an unsoftened kitchen tap for drinking and cooking, because home softeners add sodium. Never use softened water for baby formula (NHS).

Does hard water cause eczema?

+

A study of UK babies linked harder water with more eczema, but that is an association. A UK trial found softeners did not improve existing eczema in children. Speak to your GP about eczema treatment.

How do I find out how hard my water is?

+

Enter your postcode on your water company's website. The DWI calls water over 200 mg/l as calcium carbonate hard and over 300 mg/l very hard.

Does a water filter jug soften water?

+

Jugs with a limescale cartridge reduce hardness for a while, which helps with kettle scale and taste. They do not soften a whole house.

Last updated

Sources

  1. dwi.gov.uk
  2. dwi.gov.uk
  3. nhs.uk
  4. nhs.uk
  5. nottingham.ac.uk
  6. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  7. eprints.whiterose.ac.uk
  8. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  9. corporate.unitedutilities.com

General information · Drawn from publicly available research, standards and certifications. Not medical advice. We describe what certifications test and what regulators say. We do not declare products safe or toxic.

We may earn a commission from some links. It never decides what we list. How we choose

Related guides in Eat 6 guides